Key points
- The spread is the difference between the rate you get and the mid-market rate at the time.
- On large payments, a few paise per dollar adds up to more than the bank charges.
- Comparing quotes from your AD banks for each payment is the simplest way to reduce it.
- A booked deal fixes the rate for the request; record it so the remittance can be checked.
- Money that stays in the same currency, through an EEFC or PCFC account, is not converted and carries no spread.
How the spread works
Banks quote a buying and a selling rate around the interbank market rate. The card rate for small transactions carries a wide margin; larger customers can ask the dealing desk for a quote closer to the market. The difference between the rate applied and the mid-market rate at the time is the spread, and it is a real cost of the payment.
Measuring it
Compare the rate on the bank advice with a reliable mid-market rate for the same time. Express the difference as a percentage of the amount converted, and track it by bank and by month.
A worked example
Take a payment of USD 100,000 when the mid-market rate is ₹88.00. At a card rate 0.85% away from the mid, the conversion costs about ₹74,800 more than at the mid. A negotiated margin of 0.35% costs about ₹30,800, and a dealing-desk quote 0.15% from the mid about ₹13,200. The bank charges on the advice, often a few thousand rupees, are the smaller part of the bill.
The same arithmetic works in the other direction for an exporter: the bank buys your dollars below the mid, and every paisa of that gap is income you do not receive.
Forward contracts and foreign currency accounts
A forward contract fixes the rate today for a payment or receipt on a later date. It does not remove the spread, which is built into the forward rate, but it removes the risk of the rate moving before the money moves. Quotes for forwards can be compared across banks in the same way as spot quotes.
An exporter who holds foreign currency in an EEFC account, or draws packing credit in foreign currency, can pay a foreign supplier in the same currency without converting at all. With no conversion there is no spread, and the forward contract or conversion rate on the bank request reads "not applicable".
Reducing it
- Ask each of your AD banks for a quote on larger payments, and book with the best.
- Club payments to the same supplier where the terms allow.
- Agree a margin over the market rate with your bank instead of accepting the card rate.
- Keep a history of rates booked to support the negotiation.
FxLayer's FX board prices each of your banks against the market rate, books the deal on the payment request and keeps a history of every booked rate.
Questions
Sources
This article is general information on Indian foreign exchange and tax rules as they stood on the date shown. It is not legal or tax advice. Rules and limits change; confirm the current position with your AD bank, the current RBI regulations and directions or your adviser before acting.
